John Tolley

When life throws unexpected legal challenges, finding the right attorney can be overwhelming. Whether it’s a complex insurance claim or criminal defense, John Tolley stands out for his sharp legal mind and compassionate approach. As a former prosecutor and seasoned insurance defense lawyer, Tolley has successfully handled over 45 jury trials, combining his deep expertise with personalized care for each client.

Whether you’re fighting an unjust insurance denial or facing serious criminal charges, John Tolley ensures you’re heard, supported, and defended with integrity. His 10 years of experience across multiple states and courtrooms will make sure that your case gets the fair treatment it deserves. Clients consistently praise his professionalism, quick responses, and dedication to achieving the best possible outcomes.

Practice Areas

• Insurance Claims: Handling residential and commercial property damage insurance claims, ensuring clients receive the compensation they deserve.
• Criminal Defense: From minor offenses to complex felony cases, Tolley provides robust representation in criminal defense cases, including white-collar crimes, DUIs, and violent crimes.
• Civil Litigation: Specializes in insurance defense and civil disputes involving personal and business interests.

Professional Associations

• National Institute of Trial Advocacy, Faculty Member
• New York City Bar Association, Member
• New York State Bar Association, Member
• Florida Bar Young Lawyers, Member
• Broward County Bar Association, General Member
• Brooklyn Cabinet Member of the Jewish National Fund

Jurisdictions Admitted to Practice

• State Bars:
  • Florida
  • New York
  • New Jersey
  • Pennsylvania
  • Texas
• Federal Courts:
  • U.S. Southern & Eastern Districts of New York
  • U.S. Southern & Middle Districts of Florida
  • U.S. District Court of New Jersey

Achievements

• Super Lawyers Rising Star (2021, 2022)
  Recognized for his exceptional legal skills and achievements.
• National Trial Lawyers Top 100 (2021)
  A prestigious award for top trial lawyers nationwide.
• Lawyers of Distinction Excellence in Insurance Law (2020, 2021)
  Honored for excellence in the field of insurance law.
• Premier Lawyers of America – Top 40 Under 40 & Top 1% in Insurance Coverage (2020)
  Awarded for superior qualifications in legal practice.

Education

• Nova Southeastern University, Shepard Broad College of Law
  Juris Doctor (2014), with honors.
• University of Central Florida
  Bachelor of Science, Double Major in Legal Studies and Criminal Justice (2011).

Soft Perks & Fees

• Free Consultation:
  Offers a 30-minute free consultation to assess client needs and provide preliminary legal advice.
• Flexible Payment Options:
  Accepts credit cards, and offers contingent fees for certain cases.
• Video Conferencing:
  Available through Google Meet, Zoom, Skype, and more for convenient legal consultations.

Contact Information

New York Office
JT Law Firm PA
395 Ave X, 2nd Floor,
Brooklyn, NY 11223
Phone: (718) 650-5858
Hours: Mon-Fri, 8:30 AM – 6 PM

Florida Offices:
Boca Raton Office
7700 Congress Ave, Suite 1103,
Boca Raton, FL 33487
Phone: (954) 996-9996

Orlando Office
411 North Orange Ave,
Suite 800, Orlando, FL 32801
Phone: (407) 597-7777

FAQs

What makes John Tolley different from other lawyers?

With over 45 jury trials under his belt and experience as a prosecutor, John Tolley offers a unique blend of litigation skills and insurance defense expertise. His clients consistently praise his personalized approach and tireless work ethic.

Is John Tolley licensed in multiple states?

Yes, he is licensed to practice in Florida, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Texas, with admission to several federal courts.

Does he offer remote consultations?

Yes, John provides video conferencing options through platforms like Zoom, Google Meet, and Skype for clients who need virtual consultations.